9 Reasons Why Nonprofits Should Be Sharing Donor Stories

Most of the time when nonprofit organizations are sharing stories, we are hearing from staff members, the founder and clients. All of these are perfectly fine stories to tell... but what about sharing the donor stories?
Regular donors don’t give by accident. There’s a heartfelt reason they believe in your cause. With so many nonprofits to choose from, why do they continue to support yours? Potential donors need to hear those stories. Here are nine reasons why sharing donor stories matters.
1. We Tell a Lot of Stories—But Not All of Them
Most of the time, when nonprofit organizations share stories, we hear from staff members, founders, and clients. These are all important and meaningful perspectives. But there’s one group whose stories are often missing from the narrative: your donors.
What about the people who choose—again and again—to invest in your mission?
2. Every Donor Has a “Why”
When a nonprofit has regular donors, there’s almost always a story behind why they believe in the cause so deeply. Out of countless organizations they could support, why do they choose yours? That decision is rarely random. It’s rooted in emotion, personal experience, and connection.
3. Belief Is the Common Thread
Many donors relate deeply to your mission. They believe what you believe about a problem that needs to be addressed—and they want to be part of the solution. Some may have lived through a traumatic experience your organization helps others navigate. Others may support your work because they’ve seen firsthand what happens when that problem goes unaddressed. Their belief is personal, and that’s what makes their story powerful.
4. Your Donors Are Part of the Organization
Getting to know your donors matters. Be curious about them. They aren’t just financial supporters—they are a vital part of your organization’s ecosystem, just like your staff and the people you serve. When you share donor stories, you invite them further into the mission. You also create an opportunity for potential donors to see themselves reflected in those stories
.
5. Donors Give Because of Stories
People don’t give because they’re coerced. They give because they’re moved. Donations come from emotion, connection, and a desire to belong to something bigger than oneself. Storytelling opens relationships—and relationships are how wallets open and lives are transformed.
6. Belonging Is a Powerful Motivator
Everyone wants to know they matter. That they’re needed, wanted, and appreciated. When donors see the impact of their gift through storytelling, it reinforces that sense of belonging. Engagement shouldn’t only happen when you need something from them. Invite them into the journey. Make them feel like true partners in the work.
7. Questions That Unlock Powerful Donor Stories
To get started, here are a couple of questions that can spark meaningful soundbites when interviewing donors:
- What happened in your life that makes you so compelled to support our cause?
- Why is this need so important to address?
These questions keep the focus on their story while naturally connecting back to your mission.
8. Storytelling Reinforces Why They Give
By asking these questions and sharing donor stories, you’re doing more than creating content—you’re reminding donors why they chose to give in the first place. Their words and experiences may also encourage others who see themselves in that story to take action.
9. Be Curious—These Are the Stories We Never Ask For
So many donor stories go untold simply because no one asks. By being curious and sharing THEIR story, you're showing them you not only care about them helping your cause, but you care about them as people. And who doesn't like to share their story with someone who is truly interested?
Let's talk about more sharing donor stories today.


















